The building at 27 East Main Street dates to about 1908 and started out as a garage. On the morning of June 2 the fire never reached it. Smoke from next door got into every room, and its owner, Allyson Rich-Morren, told the Daily Record three weeks later that the interior was "down to the beams."
Walk the block today and the doors that are open are on Rich-Morren's side. The fire started in Cafe Crevier just before 1 a.m., and the storefronts on that lot are still dark. One of them will open under a different name. To see why, you need to know who owns which wall.
Two lots, four businesses, one property line
The Daily Record's June 23 report laid out the setup. The fire touched two attached lots with two businesses on each. Rich-Morren owns one lot. Her family's A&R Interiors shares it with Throttle Racing Club. Cafe Crevier and Chocolatine, the French pastry shop, share the other.
| Address | Business | Lot | How the fire reached it |
|---|---|---|---|
| 23 East Main Street | Chocolatine | Fire-side lot | Fire and smoke spread in from next door |
| 25 East Main Street | Cafe Crevier | Fire-side lot | Where the fire started |
| 27 East Main Street | A&R Interiors | Rich-Morren's lot | Smoke came through the Throttle space |
| 27A East Main Street | Throttle Racing Club | Rich-Morren's lot | Heavy smoke damage, no flames |
Denville Now reported that a passerby called in the fire. Its report described heavy interior damage, structural damage and a partial roof collapse at Cafe Crevier, which left that building unusable. On the other lot, the Daily Record reported, Rich-Morren's building took no fire damage, but smoke ruined most of A&R's inventory and the walls had to be replaced.
That difference explains how the next five months went. Smoke damage meant remediation crews and new stock, while the fire-side lot needed its building dealt with first, which put lease terms and owners' decisions at the center.
The smoke side came back first
Throttle Racing Club had about 36 hours of business before the fire. Owners Chris Soto and Steve Osorio, friends since childhood, held a soft opening on May 31. According to Denville Now, the flames never reached their space, but the smoke forced them to replace ceiling panels, insulation and much of their coffee and food inventory. They moved the grand opening from June 6 to June 13 and held a 9:30 a.m. ribbon cutting that Mayor Tom Andes was expected to attend.
"We were very lucky," Osorio told the Daily Record. "It could have been catastrophic in every which way."
Throttle has since become something downtown didn't have before. Denville Now's October 2026 coffee guide lists these hours:
- Monday to Thursday: 8 a.m. to 8 p.m.
- Friday and Saturday: 8 a.m. to 10 p.m.
- Sunday: 8 a.m. to 6 p.m.
Those are the latest hours of any café in town, so Throttle is one of the few places for coffee after dinner. The house coffee comes from a small family farm in Colombia owned by relatives of Lena and Laura, the owners' wives, who also help run the shop. The racing simulators come in motion and static versions and are sold in 15-minute blocks. The club's simulator page says to book in the store and to arrive 15 minutes before your session.
A&R Interiors had more to rebuild. The family design firm has been part of Denville since 1979. Rich-Morren and her mother, Adrienne Rich, ran it first on Broadway and moved it to East Main in 2016. In June, Rich-Morren said the hardest loss was inventory: fabrics, upholstery and one-of-a-kind pieces that can't be replaced. Her designers kept working from a rented space and from meetings around town. "We have had meetings in Starbucks," she said. "We had a meeting in Dunkin' Donuts. We've had meetings in so many different places, including Throttle."
She told the paper she was aiming to reopen the showroom "by the second or third week of July." She also planned to clean up the smoke-damaged samples and, as she put it, "have a great big fire sale. For real, in September or October." A&R's showroom is at 27 East Main Street and offers design services, furniture, fabrics, window treatments and lighting. Call the shop before you stop in.
The fire side is changing hands
On the other lot, the timeline depends on the building and the leases more than on cleanup crews.
Cafe Crevier opened at 25 East Main in 2022 and was known for its thin-crust pizza. Patch noted that Dave Portnoy rated the pie an 8.5. The morning after the fire, the café posted, "Luckily, no one was hurt." In its October guide, Denville Now listed Cafe Crevier as closed since June 2 and noted that the owners have said on social media that their story is not over.
Chocolatine at 23 East Main will not reopen there. Owner Cedric Hosy trained in pastry in Lyon. He told Daily Voice in late October that leaving was not his choice and that he had wanted to reopen at that address. The Morris Plains Chocolatine at 690 Speedwell Avenue is still open. For Denville customers, that is now the closest place to find his pastries.
In the same Daily Voice report, Hosy said Nick Conforti is taking over the space. Conforti is a former Cafe Crevier partner and owns Angeloni's Pizzeria at 6 Brookside Avenue in Caldwell. Angeloni's is known for its "Thinny Thin" pizza, also has a Sparta location, and got an 8.8 from Portnoy's One Bite reviews. If that plan holds, a thin-crust pizza operator with ties to the old Cafe Crevier ends up two doors from where Cafe Crevier stood. That would be the clearest sign yet that the block is rebuilding around its old pizza reputation.
Where the morning coffee run moved
For people who started the day at Cafe Crevier or Chocolatine, the morning walk now ends somewhere else. Denville Now's October 2026 guide lists the nearby options, by opening time:
- Carver's, 38 First Avenue: Opens at 6 a.m. daily, earliest in town, and serves breakfast and lunch from a scratch kitchen until 3 p.m.
- Sweet Vinyl Cafe, 23 Diamond Spring Road: Opens at 6:30 a.m. Tuesday through Friday and is closed Mondays. You can browse records while you wait for your latte.
- The Barn Cafe, 32 Broadway: Opens at 7 a.m. on weekdays and 8 a.m. on weekends. It serves farm-to-table brunch, and regulars order the dirty chai and the Chagaccino.
- Throttle Racing Club, 27A East Main Street: Opens at 8 a.m. and is still the only one of the four on the fire block itself.
- SmartWorld Coffee, 41 Diamond Spring Road, and Beignets, 45 Broadway: Both are good for a bagel or a made-to-order donut, but neither posts fixed hours, so call ahead.
For pastry, Cleopatra Sweets at 34 First Avenue serves coffee with its desserts.
There will also be a new lunch option at the other end of downtown. Tony Boy's Sandwich House lists a Denville location at 2 Broadway, with sandwiches, salads, cheesesteaks, shakes and catering.
The fund that ends in the corridor either way
The Downtown Denville Business Improvement District started an online donation campaign in June for the businesses the fire hit directly. The BID is a 501(c)(3) nonprofit. A subcommittee hands out the money through a formal application, and the BID board approves each decision in open public meetings.
The rules also say what happens if insurance or other aid fully covers a business. In the BID's words, quoted by the Daily Record, "any remaining funds will be dedicated to improvements within the impacted Main Street corridor to support revitalization efforts and strengthen the area for the future." So money given to the campaign stays on this stretch of East Main, either with the owners rebuilding or in improvements to the block. The donation page is still up.
Five months on, Throttle is pouring coffee on Rich-Morren's lot, and A&R's showroom at 27 East Main is the place to call before you visit. The lot next door is waiting on the building and on whoever holds the leases. If you own a home near downtown Denville and want to know how changes like these on East Main and Broadway affect what your house is worth, Jillayne Southren can walk you through it. Get your free home valuation or schedule a personal consultation, and we can meet for coffee at one of the places on this list.